Which ‘Sterling Point’ Stars Are — And Aren’t — Returning for Season 2 After Plot Twist Ending?

While the vision for Sterling Point includes more seasons, is every cast member coming back for a potential season 2?

The show, which is streaming now, follows Annie Jacobson (Ella Rubin), whose life takes a turn when she inherits her mysterious grandfather’s island in Canada. This leads to new friends, a love triangle and shocking family secrets being exposed — including a secret sister named Ramona (played by Amélie Hoeferle).

Sterling Point hails from creator Megan Park, who had her own coming-of-age journey after getting her start as an actress on then-ABC Family’s The Secret Life of the American Teenager. She then made the move to writing and directing with 2021’s The Fallout and 2024’s My Old Ass, which allowed Park to expand her storytelling vision.

“It would be so thrilling and such a gift if we got to do more. It was so shocking how different it was to film a show,” she told Us in July 2026. “A movie is an hour and a half and it’s a much shorter period of time that you have to make it and put it out into the world. It’s eight hours of something. So it was a lot of work and it’s been a long process.”

Park continued: “I wouldn’t say it almost killed me but it definitely aged me 10 to 20 years. It was also really rewarding though because within an hour and a half, you can only go so deep and you can only explore so much and talk about so much. When you have eight hours, you have a much bigger world and so many more characters. So it was really creatively rewarding in that sense. But I’m not going to lie, it’s a lot of work making a TV show.”

The showrunner addressed the way season 1 ended with a plot twist.

“I knew that we always wanted Ramona and Annie to switch places. It was just like, ‘How do we get them there and how do we show that?’ Because I think it’s really important for them to experience each other’s worlds for a little bit of time and see how that shapes them and see how that makes them understand each other or not understand each other,” Park teased. “And also Connor reaching out to his biological parents was something that was really important to me — without Annie’s knowledge — which is a pretty bold and dramatic move.”

Park promised a “great setup” for season 2, adding, “But also if we don’t, it’s like you are kind of [leaving] people wondering what happened to them. But yeah, hopefully it sets us up for a nice season 2.”

Keep scrolling to see who is and isn’t coming back on Sterling Point:

Ella Rubin

Season 2 would follow Rubin’s character Annie after she chose to stay on the island.

Amélie Hoeferle

Hoeferle’s character, Ramona, meanwhile, chose to swap places with Annie by moving to New York.

Jacob Whiteduck-Lavoie

While Annie and Ellis called it quits when she was planning to leave, their romance will presumably be front and center in season 2.

Daniel Quinn-Toye

Quinn-Toye’s Rory didn’t end up with Annie but he could still be back.

Bo Bragason

Bragason, who plays Oona, is expected back after Ramona’s split from her friend.

Keen Ruffalo

Ruffalo’s character, Connor, had a smaller role in season 1 but will likely be back.

Mabel Strachan

Maple a.k.a Oona’s younger sister is presumably returning in the sophomore season.

Missi Pyle

Pyle’s character, Denise, made appearances in season 1, which will likely continue in future episodes.

Jay Duplass

After finding out that he is (spoiler!) Ramona’s biological father, Steven’s role would likely be expanded.

Jeffrey Dean Morgan

Morgan told Us he had high hopes for more storylines for the adults in season 2.